Dear Rabbi and Susan,
I am a practicing physician working during tremendous change in healthcare over 25 years. These changes are in a negative direction: increased bureaucracy that decreases quality and access, and decreased autonomy and financial reimbursements for complicated, hard work. I have witnessed many physicians with years of experience and wisdom retire early or leave clinical practice for other work because of these overwhelming negative forces. I don’t know any physicians whose children are in medical school or aspire to attend.
Despite this negative environment, our son wants to go to medical school. He is excelling in college coursework and is unwavering in his pursuit of this goal. I have been thoughtful to project a balanced and realistic view of my career in Emergency Medicine. Within a very frustrating environment of decline, I still find patient care a privilege and incredibly fascinating. I feel I still make a positive difference in individual patients’ lives. I see areas of opportunity with the wise use of technology and new political leadership committed to reducing bureaucracy. But I am uncertain how to best mentor our son about such a big commitment (financial and time) to a career with so many negative trends. My husband also has mixed feelings about our son’s career in medicine. We want to be on the “same page”.
Knowing the challenges in healthcare yet optimistic about a new generation to restore and renew physician autonomy, what does ancient Jewish wisdom say about advising young adults about career choices? Balancing passion with practicality? Being a Happy Warrior and unified as parents when discussing complicated life choices? Does the Lapin team (you, Susan, or your daughter Rebecca and her husband) have plans to release a coaching program for parenting young adults transitioning into careers and family formation? This would be a wonderful addition to your fantastic library!
With gratitude,
Mom
Dear Mom,
You may know Ruchi Koval from her book Soul Construction, Shape Your Character Using 8 Steps From The Timeless Jewish Practice Of Mussar, that we were proud to publish. Lately, Ruchi has devoted much time to guiding parents in their relationships with adult children so we turned to her with your question.
We think she presented a wise approach to your dilemma, however after her answer we have added one concern that is more our department than hers.
You sound like an incredibly devoted and thoughtful mother who has striven to function as a positive role model for your child, while also continuing to be available as a mentor as he transitions into adulthood. So first off, let me applaud you for that, because you are already significantly ahead of the pack in this area. Your son is very blessed to have you as his parent.
That having been said, I can’t help but notice that your dilemma seems to be entirely self-enclosed, meaning it doesn’t seem that your son is asking you for advice on this matter. On the contrary, he seems to be confident and passionate about his career choice. In other words, you are wavering — not him.
But your child is an adult at this point. And therefore the problem is yours to resolve within your own mindset. Your son doesn’t have a problem, because he is not conflicted; you have a problem, because you are conflicted.
So how can we help to resolve your conflict? Allow me to offer you a few reframes.
Number one, I often counsel that in parenting we have three stages: manager, supervisor and consultant.
We are “managers” for our children all through the elementary school years and through middle school. When they become adolescents, we have to transition to supervisors, backing off a bit and giving them some space to fail and make mistakes while the stakes are low. Of course, we are there to supervise and step in when necessary, but we start to play a more backseat role.
When our kids become adults, we need to step back further and become consultants. When do consultants give advice? When asked. Right now you are functioning in your son‘s life as a consultant. And… he didn’t ask.
The second reframe I have for you is wisdom from King Solomon in the book of Proverbs. King Solomon famously says, “Educate a child according to his way.” What this means is that each child will have a different personality and different drives. Your son seems to have discovered his, which is incredible. Let him go according to his way. He needs to travel his own path.
The third reframe I’d like to offer is how wonderful it is that in this era of extremely frustrating healthcare, someone incredible like your son can step in to make things better. This is indeed a blessing, for you, for him and for the world. I pray that you can see it as such.
Ruchi Koval
We think that Ruchi gave great advice. The one area we wish to add is the financial aspect. Will your son be requesting or depending on financial support from you and your husband as he progresses into and with his medical training? If so, you have the obligation to sit down with him and ask him to reassure you that he has thought about and planned for the financial matters.
If he is managing alone, requiring no monies or guarantees from you, you should ask him if he’d be comfortable with sitting down with you to discuss his choice and the financial considerations.
These include the possibility of six-figure debt by the time he takes his first job as a physician.
You also want to know that he has a realistic understanding of what remuneration might look like in the profession by the time he enters it. Finally, does he have a realistic understanding of how well his chosen profession will integrate with the lifestyle he anticipates in terms of marriage and family.
May God bless you with much pride and joy in the achievements of your children,
Rabbi Daniel and Susan Lapin
What do you think? We’d love to hear your thoughts on this Ask the Rabbi & Susan post.
We Happy Warrior members can both read and write comments HERE.
Not a member yet? Ask the Rabbi is a reader-supported publication.
We truly appreciate those of you who sign up for a Basic membership. This lets us know we are providing value to you.

In Nurturing Toddlers, Rebecca Masinter equips you with the tools and clarity you need to thrive through the toddler years with confidence and joy.
See what Penina and Bexley have to say:
“In Nurturing Toddlers, expert parenting coach Rebecca Masinter presents an absolute masterclass in claiming your rightful role as the loving, knowledgeable, empowered parent in your toddler’s life…Chock of parenting gold.” – Penina Zussman
“Incredibly insightful… I’m already finding small ways to shift my approach and see real results with my kids.” – Bexley Liss



