Dear Rabbi Daniel Lapin,
Greetings from Nairobi, Kenya.
My name is Michael Ngige Karanja. I am 34 years old, a Christian, a husband, and a father to a wonderful two-year-old son. For many years, I have worked as a teacher, and I am now prayerfully transitioning into business and entrepreneurship, particularly within the field of educational and teaching services here in Nairobi.
I am intentionally applying the principles and teachings from your book diligently and thoughtfully as I seek to build wealth ethically, purposefully, and in a God-honoring way. However, I would be grateful for further guidance regarding one important question.
In the example on pages 375–377, the transaction involves physical goods — shoes. In my case, I am venturing into a service-based business, particularly teaching English and educational services. Since teaching is intangible and cannot be measured like physical inventory, how should I correctly understand and calculate the value being created for clients?
For example:
● How should a teacher or consultant determine the true value of services offered?
● How do I measure whether the client genuinely received greater value than the price paid?
● In Torah-based economic thinking, how is wealth creation understood in service businesses where transformation, knowledge, confidence, and communication skills are the “product”?As someone transitioning from employment into entrepreneurship, I desire to build a business founded not merely on profit, but on genuine value creation and service to people.
Thank you once again for writing such an edifying and transformative book. Your teachings are reaching and impacting lives far beyond America — even here in Nairobi, Kenya.
I would be deeply honored to learn more from your wisdom and guidance.
Michael
Dear Michael,
We so appreciated your letter. Your sincerity and desire to build a business with integrity and righteousness is admirable.
Thank you for raising the question you did. We think it is one you share with many others. But many of the same principles apply to service businesses as apply to those with physical inventory.
Right up front, we must help you correct your thinking in one vitally important area. The words we use betray our thinking and you reveal a grievous glitch in your thinking with these words you wrote: “…I desire to build a business founded not merely on profit, but on genuine value creation and service to people….”
“Not merely on profit” Michael Ngige Karanja? Then on what? Genuine value creation and service to people, you respond. But how would you know that you have created genuine value? How would you know if you have provided real service to people? The answer? Right–PROFIT! It is never “merely profit”. Profit is everything. It is what tells you that you are serving God’s other children and providing them with what they need or want.
If your best friend looks at your product and enthusiastically reacts: “How wonderful Michael–you have created a very valuable product; it is worth at least $100. However, while he himself does not reach into his pocket to pay you $100, along comes a stranger and eagerly offers you $50 for the product, you now have a starting price point for your product. Its value is always determined by what ‘the market’ is willing to pay, in this case, $50, not $100.
When pricing a physical item, the business professional takes into account variables including initial cost, marketing, infrastructure, and the labor involved in making a sale. He looks at others selling similar products to get a feel for the market.
Is the service industry so different? People are not paying for the specific time you spend with them. They are paying for your training, development—in other words your initial cost—and the infrastructure that allows you to help them. Basically, they are paying for how you improve the quality of their lives. There are others delivering similar services that allow you to get a feel for the market. As in any business, supply vs. demand plays an intrinsic role.
Just as one purse sells for $39.99 while another sells for $439.99, there may be factors that allow you to charge more. That may be a feature of clever marketing, but more realistically and more upright, it will be a feature of reputation acquired over years.
We encourage you to rethink these words: “transformation, knowledge, confidence, and communication skills are the “product.” If you are teaching English, it makes a difference if you are teaching children who might be future immigrants to English speaking countries or business professionals who want to communicate with clients and peers. Are you coaching lawyers who need to perfectly understand each word in a document or a vendor who wants to respond to customer complaints? The product is your client’s ability to do something they were unable to do previously. Your fee partially depends on how important that goal is to them and how uniquely suited you are to help them reach that goal.
Bottom line, make sure that you go through the exercise of writing a proper formal business plan, even if you are not seeking investors. Just for yourself. It will greatly clarify your thinking. Once you have written down clearly the problem that your product will solve and how you know it is a problem that plagues people, you will know the answers to some of the questions you raise in your letter. Once you identify who the customers of your product will be, you will be close to finding the answers to the remaining questions you ask.
Wishing you very profitable endeavors
Rabbi Daniel and Susan Lapin
Enjoyed this article? Feel free to share it using this link: https://rabbidaniellapin.com/what-if-my-product-isnt-a-product/

Hands Off! This May Be Love – Limited Offer!
How do you cultivate a new relationship so that it grows into a lasting marriage?
It might be counter-cultural, but there’s a strong Biblical, biological, and psychological case for not becoming physically intimate while dating. Renowned dating coach Gila Manolson’s powerful book, Hands Off! This May Be Love makes a compelling case.
For a limited time, save:
📘 Paperback — Now $12.95
📱 eBook — Now $9.95
👉 Get Your Copy Today
Sharing with a group? Bulk orders of 30 books are available for just $150 ($5 per book). Simply select “Bulk Order 30” from the Format dropdown on the product page.



