The Road Ends

For the eight months following the massacre in Israel on October 7, 2023, our blogs listed one name and profile of an individual who had been murdered and another name and profile of someone who had been taken hostage. Compiling this list became somewhat of a sacred activity for me.

As our beloved daughter, Rena, neared the end of her days, my focus narrowed to our own family and I halted this emotionally taxing task. This week, when the news broke that the army uncovered the bodies of six of the hostages who were murdered in cold blood, I recognized the names. We had profiled some of them. One, Hersh Goldberg-Polin, was an American citizen whose parents have been relentless in keeping his name in the world’s consciousness.

No less an authority than God Himself describes the Jews as stiff-necked. This idea resonates with the tired – but accurate – claim of “two Jews, three opinions.” We have Israeli friends who despise Benjamin Netanyahu and those who greatly admire him; relatives who are desperate for hostage negotiations to take place no matter what and those who are convinced that overwhelming military force is the only road to the future.

That apparent disunity masks the cohesiveness and mutual responsibility people in this country feel for each other. Israel is a country in pain and in mourning, but it is also a country that feels more vibrant and optimistic than the cities with which we are familiar in the United States. What is reported in the American press, even well-intentioned press, is rarely accurate or complete.

We are in Israel as I write. One of our grandsons started first grade on Monday and the opening of school featured a ceremony where the older grades welcomed these young, incoming students. The sixth-grade girls, members of the senior class, performed a welcome skit, one that they had conceived, written, directed, and practiced in the last week of their summer vacation. Similar ceremonies took place in schools around the country. Older students are taught to feel responsible for helping the younger ones acclimate and integrate into the social group.

Although the news of the six executed hostages was released not long before the ceremony took place, there were no groups of huddled parents looking anxious and broken. I assume that anyone directly affected stayed home, but Israel is a small country and the entire nation was horrified and in mourning. However, those emotions were quarantined from the school event. Here there was only a celebration of learning, school pride, and student cohesiveness. The hostages and Israel’s soldiers were mentioned and prayed for alongside prayers for a successful school year, but in an example of how sorrow and joy, tears and smiles go together in Israel, the celebratory nature of the event was not detracted from even if many of the parents cried before they came and after they returned home.

On Monday, the morning of Hersh Goldberg-Polin’s funeral, an eight-day-old Israeli baby boy whose parents did not personally know Hersh or his family, was named after him. That is Israel. Everyone feels connected and, at the same time, there is an exquisite awareness of life needing to continue rather than letting despair engulf you.

My husband and I went out for a stroll in the beautiful town in which our children live. Alongside cafes and shops, people working and playing, amidst vibrant and vital life, these are a few of the signs we saw.


This empty chair outside a restaurant shows a picture of hostage Romi Gonan. The sign says, Congratulations my sister on your 24th (birthday). It’s a shame that you are noting this day in the hands of Hamas. I am waiting for you at home.

This sign says: Take them out of Hell

This sign features hostages Eli and Yossi Sharabi surrounded by pictures of other hostages and those who were murdered.

These are pictures of those murdered on October 7 and/or killed in battle since then and reads: In their death they commanded us victory.

This sign reads: Bring them home now!

There is no forgetting that tens of thousands of Israelis are exiled from their homes due to the constant threat of and bombardment by missiles. There is no failing to see that many families are functioning with husbands and fathers away for months fighting. There is no pretending that notices of tragic deaths are not a feature of daily life. There is vigorous, passionate debate about how to survive while being assaulted by barbaric evil. And at the same time, there are engagements, weddings, births, and celebrations of life. Funerals and first-grade beginnings—a stiff-necked nation endures.


What do you think? We’d love to hear your thoughts on this Susan’s Musings post.
We Happy Warrior members can both read and write comments HERE.

Not a member yet? Susan’s Musings is a reader-supported publication.
We truly appreciate those of you who sign up for a Basic membership. This lets us know we are providing value to you.


Only a Few Days Left!

Financial Prosperity Collection
Now at $99 (Save $50!)

Unlock the secrets to financial success with wisdom that has stood the test of time. Rabbi Daniel Lapin, has distilled his most impactful teachings into a 10-session, work at your own pace, video course, complete with a 56-page workbook.

What You’ll Learn:

  • Transform Your Mindset: Discover how changing the way you think about money can change your life.
  • Achieve Daily Greatness: Turn your daily grind into a path to greatness with actionable strategies.
  • Believe and Achieve: Learn why your beliefs about money are just as important as your actions.
  • Take Control of Your Financial Future: Gain practical tools to guide your financial destiny with confidence.

Get the Financial Prosperity Collection

Shopping Cart