The Harder They Fall

In 1956, Humphrey Bogart played sportswriter Eddie Willis in the last movie he made, The Harder They Fall.  After many ups and downs, Bogart’s character achieves greatness.  Have you ever heard anyone say, “I don’t want to try too hard because I don’t need to be wildly successful,” or, “I don’t want to rise too far because the tallest tree catches the wind”?  Many of us have impeded our own progress by warning ourselves that reaching for the sky can bring a great fall.

While there may be some good reasons not to clamber up the cliff, that old Humpty Dumpty rationale isn’t it. Impeding our progress by warning ourselves that reaching for the sky can bring a great fall leads to not reaching our potential, a crime against ourselves and our Creator. It is so easy to succumb to wrong-headed thinking and sabotage our own potential that Scripture projects a powerful message to deter us.

Whenever a specific phrase is found in more than one location in Scripture, we are intended to compare and contrast the instances in which it appears.

For instance, the phase:   הִנָּ֥ךְ הָרָ֖ה וְיֹלַ֣דְתְּ בֵּ֑ן

appears in two places in the Bible; once in connection with Abraham’s first son, Yishmael, and again in connection with Samson.

The phrase has two meanings:

Behold you have conceived and will give birth to a son
(Yishmael; Genesis 16:11)


Behold you shall conceive and will give birth to a son
(Samson; Judges 13:5)

Since the tense of the English translation varies, many people with no access to Hebrew (and no rabbi) remain oblivious to the fact that both verses contain the identical phrase.

In fact, these are the only two instances in the Tanach of an angel directly informing a woman that she will soon give birth.  But that is where the similarities end. Among many other differences, the two sons marry differently.

Ishmael’s mother, Hagar, finds her son a wife:

…and his mother took him a wife from Egypt
(Genesis 21:21)

Samson finds his own wife, despite his parents’ disapproval of her (but in concert with God’s plan):

…get her for me as a wife
(Judges 14:2)

Yishmael’s life follows a steady trajectory from his birth in Genesis 16 until his death in Genesis 25.

Samson’s life is clearly divided into two sections.

From his birth in Judges 13 until the end of Judges 15, we see the Lord is with him constantly.

The second part of Samson’s life begins with him consorting with a harlot (Judges 16:1) and concludes with his death (Judges 16:30). During this time the Lord appears to have abandoned him.

Contrast the two phrases which conclude the two parts of Samson’s life:

And he judged Israel in the days of the Philistines twenty years.
  (Judges 15:20)

…and he judged Israel twenty years. 
(Judges 16:31)

Ancient Jewish wisdom teaches that during the first half of his life his purpose and mission was defeating the Philistines and protecting Israel from them.  During the second part of his life, he largely forgot his mission.

Yishmael, even though he and his progeny were promised blessing by God, lived a largely uneventful life.

Samson, the heroic Hebrew Judge, lived a turbulent life the beginning of which he lived in accordance with God’s wishes and enjoying His blessings.  Tragically the latter part of his life was lived without his mission, without God, and without His blessings.

The contrast is between two men both of whose births were heralded by an angel and both of whom were blessed.  One became an ordinary man who never achieved any great good and never did any great wrong. The other became a larger-than-life figure, a giant man with giant abilities and giant appetites.  He played a vital role in Israel’s history, achieving enormous triumphs but also sinking to tragic depths.

Samson remains a Hebrew hero; flawed but heroic.  His passion for life led him to heights and his weaknesses led to his downfall.  But it wasn’t inevitable and he serves as a far better model than Yishmael.

God created us with the potential for greatness.  We all possess the potential for doing great good, but also for failing disastrously.  Being great doesn’t mean never desiring to do wrong or never doing wrong.  It means developing our resistance to wrongdoing.  With the lesson of Samson fresh in our minds, we can throw ourselves into the struggle for greatness confident that we will reap its blessings and fight its dangers.

Do you enjoy going deeper into the Bible? 

The Genesis Journey Set

See the Hebrew for yourself in our recommended Hebrew/English Bible

Genesis Journey Set Instant Download Genesis Journeys Set


11 thoughts on “The Harder They Fall”

  1. What a blessing your teachings are. Thank you. My husband and I are constantly learning and growing. When you give a new insight that we perhaps had not see before my husband is always astounded that he could go for 66 years, being raised in a Christian church, and not known this! I look at it through the light that we never stop learning, growing and seeing new insight until the day we die. Certainly we cannot hold our past teachers accountable for not giving us every lesson and insight there is in the Bible before we are 25 and then expecting us to never forget any of that teaching for the remainder of your life – that would be ridiculous! I hope I’m still receiving new insights into God’s word until the day I die and thankfully you are a major source of that learning – as is my church.
    Blessings to you and Susan

  2. The angels on their way to Sodom and Gomorrah tell Abraham, with Sarah listening at the door of the tent, that Sarah will have birth to a son (Yitzhak/Isaac, Yishmael’s half-brother). The angel knew Sarah was listening and the angel speaks to Sarah about the future birth in Genesis 18:15. So doesn’t that make at least three instances? Also, Yishmael’s life and death is summed up in Genesis 25. Rashi’s comments there seem to say he was righteous but after Abraham died he fell away from righteousness.

    1. I think the Rabbi said the Angel informed the woman directly. In the case of Abraham the angels were speaking directly to Abraham and Sarah was listening from inside the tent.

  3. How blessed are we to have such a wonderful Rabbi!
    Absolutely life changing.. and forever grateful for teaching us how to get back up, and get moving from the depths of God’s Word.
    Thought Tools, Susan’s Musings, and your YouTube teachings have been a faithful gift of some needed structure and routine to look forward to, during this past challenging year.
    Thanking God always for the Lapin team!

  4. I recently read that the higher the spiritual heights you climb, the greater will be the evil inclination, since the purpose of life is to use our free will to choose the good which is equally balanced with the evil.
    It was quite jarring to realize this – but Samson seems to be the cautionary tale

  5. As always you open up wisdom that is not only historical but brings us face to face with our own current day lives . You always amaze me how you Keep cracking open nuggets of wisdom.

  6. Rabbi Daniel, this is another great article. Thank you. I am grateful.
    I have a question, How do one develop resistance to wrongdoing?

    1. I am also very interested to know how you would answer this question, Rabbi.

      One of the ways I’ve found and have learned over the years is to not give into the lustful desires of the flesh. Another way is to not go to places where you know there is temptation.

      There is a Bible verse in James 4:7 that says “Submit yourselves, then, to God. Resist the devil,and he will flee from you.”

Comments are closed.

Shopping Cart