Take Two: Purging Evil from Our Midst

I hope you have read our grandson Eliyahu’s post, Purging Evil from Our Midst. My husband and I are incredibly proud and moved that so many of our older grandchildren felt such deep sadness at Charlie Kirk’s assassination. These include Eliyahu’s sixteen-year-old sister and our fourteen-year-old Israeli grandson, who personally knows young men who have been killed by terrorist organizations supported by the growing numbers on the Left and increasingly on the extreme Right as well. We see these grandchildren absorbing our values and those of their parents, thinking them through, and making them their own; this is deeply gratifying.

So, it is with much love that I asked Eliyahu’s permission to write a rebuttal to a claim that he made. Not only did he grant it, but he told me that it was a point he wished he had elaborated on. Which claim? One he asserted with righteous and deserved indignation:

“Those who celebrate the death of Charlie must be entirely eradicated from public life. They should never hold a job again, their employers must be boycotted and shamed, they must be expelled from university, and these cretins of evil must be eternal outcasts of polite society. No more dialogue with those who cheer for slaughter.”


I agree with Eliyahu, with one caveat. There must be room for repentance. We are in the time of year that, in Jewish understanding, is a time of judgment. God judges us for the actions of the past year, and we plead for His compassion for our sins and omissions. Yet, these days are celebratory, not dismal. We firmly believe that if we confess, repent and change our ways, and commit to doing better, God will accept our remorse. We may still face punishment, but the road back to a relationship with God is always open.

We must offer no less to our fellow human beings. The gleeful chortling of the mob about Charlie Kirk’s assassination is heinous. That in itself is serving as a wake-up call to many who accepted the lie of the “compassionate Left.” But there are sick souls who are part of that mob who have rarely in their entire lives heard anything other than hatred for Christianity, conservatives, men, and other ostensibly “privileged” groups. Their parents, teachers, and/or universities seduced them to applauding foul ideas and to believing that men like Charlie Kirk are evil budding Hitlers. The internet has radicalized and severely damaged many more young people. These foolish individuals have been diligently internalizing perverse and destructive thinking, and in doing so are a danger to civilization. They must be staunchly opposed.

However, some of them will find the road to repentance. Ancient Jewish wisdom speaks approvingly of a sage named Raish Lakish. He had been a notorious and vicious bandit who came to know God. He turned his life around and became a teacher and mentor whose words still guide us today. John Newton was a British slave ship captain in the 1700s who recognized the evil in which he was immersed and repented. He became a Christian cleric, wrote the exquisite words of the hymn, Amazing Grace, and was instrumental in the fight to end slavery.

I do not know how many young (or older) people on the Left will answer a call to repentance. Recognizing that you have been caught in a web of lies, that your actions shame you rather than bring you credit, and walking away from those who have led you astray is no easy task. It is a gargantuan moral challenge made more daunting by the contempt that will be aimed at you by your former comrades. It takes humility, an openness of spirit, and intellectual courage that heretofore has not been required. For most people, it will mean becoming acquainted with God.

I do believe that every parent has an obligation to know if their child’s teachers rejoice in murder. As a patient, I want to know if my doctor would celebrate the death of a patient with certain beliefs. I think that most universities need to be shut down, only to reopen if they value life and are committed to the authentic exchange of information. I might even want to know if a store I frequent employs someone driven by twisted ideologies so that I can choose to react to that information.

One of the greatest warriors against the scourge of communism was the eloquent Whittaker Chambers. He had been an ardent communist and underground supporter of the evil policies of the USSR. He repented – an act of profound courage which he describes in his classic book, Witness.

So, if in, say, five years, some of those individuals who are now posting hate-filled diatribes have charted a new course, and if they look back at themselves in 2025 with embarrassment, then I want to welcome them. We must allow them to become leaders in ensuring that next generations are not damaged as they were. I am confident that it would honor Charlie Kirk’s memory to greet them with open arms.

Enjoyed this article? Feel free to share it using this link: https://rabbidaniellapin.com/take-two-purging-evil-from-our-midst/



A Brand-New Benefit Available Exclusively to Special Access Members!

The RDL AI Virtual Guide

This AI guide is custom-built from over 11 million words of Rabbi Lapin’s teachings to communicate in Rabbi Lapin’s style. It’s like having Rabbi Lapin by your side—any time of day—to reveal how the world really works! 

Explore Special Access membership and get this brand-new benefit!

4 thoughts on “Take Two: Purging Evil from Our Midst”

Comments are closed.

Shopping Cart