Revenge!

Dear Rabbi and Susan,

What is a Biblical view of revenge and forgiveness?
S.L.

Dear S.L.,

Well, that is one way to pack a huge topic into very few words. We did change your question slightly as you specified Jewish law rather than the Bible. If you are asking in reference to a specific instance you would need to share all the personal details and hear guidance aimed specifically at you and that incident. We are choosing to respond to a more general question and so to look at this from a Biblical perspective, one which is certainly timely while nations are at war in response to actions by other nations.

The seemingly obvious place to start is Leviticus 19:18. The second half of the verse is more oft quoted than the first half, but the whole verse reads:

“You shall not take vengeance or bear a grudge against members of your people and love your fellow as yourself; I am GOD.”

There is much to unpack here including the distinction between the words translated as ‘vengeance’ and ‘grudge,’ but on the simplest level the frequently given explanation says that if you ask your neighbor to lend you his power saw and he doesn’t, but a few weeks later he shows up at your door asking to borrow your router, you must lend it to him. Furthermore, (here is the grudge part) you cannot say to him, “Even though you didn’t help me, I’m going to help you.”


That is asking us to exert control over our emotions. Indeed, the BIble does ask us to control our emotions. No Bible follower can ever whine, “I can’t help how I feel.” Let us note that this presumes as a given that you have no reason to fear that your neighbor will misuse your saw or not give it back in a timely fashion. The assumption is that there is no loss to you and only benefit to him. It behooves us to expect the best from our people unless we have a reason for not doing so. In that way we treat others as we would hope that others will treat us. We are not encouraged to be fools, only virtuous people.

You’ll notice that the example of borrowing a tool is not comparable to responding to an assault. Responding in anger is never the right path, but neither is automatically ignoring something that needs attention. Acting with vengeance or a grudge is not necessarily the opposite of ‘letting it slide.’ There are volumes that expand on this idea as it applies to someone harming you, your property, or your reputation. As we said above, there are no cut and dry answers to general questions, only to specific circumstances.

Furthermore, many don’t realize that Leviticus 19:18 is a personal admonition, not aimed at nations. A nation’s leader has the responsibility of protecting his people. In national terms, not responding to an assault can be a dereliction of duty. We respect those religious sects who will never resort to physical violence, but that isn’t our Biblical heritage. Once again, though, any response should be thought out rather than emotional.

Like all else in the written Torah, more lies beneath the surface than above it. Study is a lifetime project.

Wishing you peaceful interactions,

Rabbi Daniel and Susan Lapin

Enjoyed this article? Feel free to share it using this link: https://rabbidaniellapin.com/revenge/



Shopping Cart