Dear Rabbi and Susan,
I listened to Podcast Episode 114 regarding renting or buying. I agree with you almost 100%. I do think owning is Biblical and better for people.
This is where I think I might disagree. Perhaps you can clarify this for me.
If I have no mortgage, meaning I have the title BUT I don’t pay property tax on the assessed value, the federal government will, through their process, take my property.
Here’s my question, do I really ever own my property? Not a trick question, just a thought. Would luv to hear your thoughts.
I share your podcast with my friends, even the ones that would disagree. Great show!! Keep up the tremendous work.
A Happy Warrior,
Tyson P.
MBA, D.Min.
Dear Reverend Tyson,
Yours is certainly not a trick question. It is an important question. Firstly, one point of correction, if we may. It is unlikely to be the federal government placing a tax lien on your property for non-payment of property tax, but your local government. Either way, you are correct. Property tax is wrong and immoral. It undermines the fundamental principle of ownership.
You purchased your property with after-tax money so for the government to double tax your money by extracting a ‘rent-like’ annual tax violates your right to property and liberty. (The two are of course inextricably interlinked.) Essentially, this terrible tax converts you from an owner into a rental tenant.
What is more, because it is the taxing authority that assesses the value of your property, it is incentivized to arbitrarily raise the assessed value. We say arbitrarily because the only way to determine the true value of a property is to put it up for sale and discover what the market is willing to pay. Yet, the government decides for itself what the value is. In practice, property taxes incrementally increase; they never go down—only up.
Moving from philosophical analysis to practical living, in real life we don’t have infinite choices. If we could opt out of property tax, we would unhesitatingly do so. However, our only choices right now are renting or buying. Yes, it is true that buying is, well, sort of renting. But it is not exactly the same. Even given the inherent evils of the property tax, “owning” your property is still better than renting.
There are many reasons ranging from the economic, for example, you get to keep any increase in the value of your property, to the spiritual, for example you care about property you own more than you care about property you rent. Just check with Hertz Car Rental. It is in this context that we claim that owning with all its shortcomings is better than rental. A neighborhood made up of “homeowners” is generally a nicer, better maintained neighborhood than one made up of renters.
It’s a principle of ancient Jewish wisdom that God prefers everything to be owned. The Bible states we must return lost items to their owners (Exodus 23:4). Deuteronomy 22:1-3 even tells us that we may not ignore a lost item but rather are obligated to attempt to find the owner.
Hoping that this resolves the matter for you, dear Tyson, and that you are a happy property owner.
With warm ownership regards,
Rabbi Daniel & Susan Lapin
Enjoyed this article? Feel free to share it using this link: https://rabbidaniellapin.com/renting-vs-owning/

Looking for inspiration and practical guidance — at a fraction of the price?
Grab these gems at a price you’ll love!
UP TO 78% OFF
Closeout Books
Just $5.00 each
Dear Rabbi and Susan, Aleph-Bet, Hands Off, This May Be Love, and The Skeptic and the Rabbi
Thought Tools Book Set (3 softcover books)
$35.00 $20.00
Financial Prosperity Collection: The Ten Commandments – USB Flash Drive
$149.00 $75.00
Bulk discounts available — contact Crystol to save even more!



