As a child learning the Biblical books of Joshua, Judges, Samuel and Kings in school, I accepted the narrative at face value. As an adult studying ancient Jewish wisdom, I uncovered elements that I could not have understood at a younger age. One question continued to disturb me.
Jewish law and culture through the ages have been meticulous about respecting not only the living but also the dead. Yet the above-mentioned books of the Prophets depict many bloody scenes of mutilating bodies and in some cases decimating entire cities, including women and children. This seems out of step with basic tenets of Judaism. What to make of that dichotomy?
As someone who sees everything incorporated into the Biblical text as a message for the ages, I find myself looking at those troubling episodes differently today. They came to mind after President Trump pardoned and commuted the sentences of those who were portrayed by the press and politicians as rioters and insurrectionists for their activities on January 6, 2017. I read comments by people who voted for President Trump and supported him but felt that his actions in this case were wrong. After four years of an administration that thumbed its nose at the Constitution, the rule of law, and the norms of American society, they were disappointed that President Trump did not act purer than Caesar’s wife by evaluating each J6er individually.
This week included not only the inauguration of President Trump but also the return home of three Israeli hostages. Three women, brutally abducted and detained in inhumane conditions, were returned in exchange for the release of nearly 1,000 murderers, most of whom are committed to murdering again.
We, in most cases, are obligated to follow the laws of society. However, that social contract can break down and historically has done so in various times and places. The system only works when everyone agrees to abide by the rules of the system. Israel, whose citizens see their fellow citizens as family, cannot engage honorably with a culture that is willing to joyously sacrifice millions of its own members to achieve their political and military ends. Repeatedly, Israelis and those Moslems who have broken free from extremist Islamic tenets have been stymied at being forced to pretend that there is a shared philosophy on the value of human life. This hostage deal is an example.
What does this have to do with President Trump’s inauguration or with the books of Joshua, Judges, Samuel, and Kings? While in no way suggesting moral equivalence, it explains why I am thrilled with the president’s commutation and pardoning of everyone convicted for their actions on January 6, 2017. Shouldn’t I be indignant that even those who were charged with violence were included?
We may never know the truth of what happened on January 6. I am convinced that we were told many lies about the day, that there was a cover-up, that numerous documents and files were destroyed, and that justice was subverted, leaving American citizens detained and convicted as political prisoners. President Biden’s pardoning of the J6 committee was the final blow that convinced me that crimes were committed during that investigation.
Madeleine Murray O’Hair, the woman who brought the 1960 case to the Supreme Court that effectively removed Bible readings and prayer from public schools, recognized that she could use the United States Constitution against that country. In his book, My Life Without God, O’Hair’s son William Murray describes how his mother realized that the freedoms and rights accorded to U.S. citizens could be manipulated to destroy the United States. Laws meant to protect people could be used to harm them.
The barbaric nations occupying the land of Canaan where Joshua led the children of Israel, engaged in heinous practices including child sacrifice and fecal worship. God did not tell the Israelites to treat all the nations alike. Some could be introduced to the seven laws of the sons of Noah and given a chance to reform; others needed to be wiped out. Had the Israelites finished the task set for them, their descendants and indeed the world, might not be facing the dangers we still face today.
Perhaps one lesson from those early books of the prophets is that mistaken honor and deceptive morals can keep one from doing what is hard to do but what is necessary and right. Granted, we have no Moses or Joshua today, no prophet who can unequivocally tell us what God wants. As individuals and as nations we must stumble in the dark, attempting to follow the correct path. In this specific case, I believe that by acting decisively and quickly, President Trump showed leadership and an understanding of the perils that have confronted the constitution he has sworn to preserve, protect, and defend.
What do you think? We’d love to hear your thoughts on this Susan’s Musings post.
We Happy Warrior members can both read and write comments HERE.
Not a member yet? Susan’s Musings is a reader-supported publication.
We truly appreciate those of you who sign up for a Basic membership. This lets us know we are providing value to you.

Tower of Power: Decoding the Secrets of Babel
This new video course holds profound insights into human behavior, authoritarian power, and the challenges we face today. This ancient account is not just a historical tale but a blueprint for understanding the recurring patterns that shape our world.
Take a deep dive into Genesis, Chapter 11, with Rabbi Daniel Lapin as he unpacks the events surrounding the Tower of Babel and explore how these patterns have influenced history—and still impact us.
Start your journey with a free excerpt from our brand new course!



