I recently read a touching first-person account. The writer, after volunteering at a food bank, described serving a grateful woman who shared that she never imagined she would be in that situation. A tsunami of troubles, including divorce and losing her job, cascaded one upon the other quickly leaving her needing the handout.
The many comments that followed overwhelmingly repeated the same refrain, “We are all only one crisis from being in the same place.” Touching, empathetic, and emotional words—but are they true?
I agree that we are all potentially one step from a crisis. For this reason, we need to be in a state of constant gratitude for every healthy day, every safe trip, every moment the streets outside our home are peaceful, and innumerable other blessings. But looking more deeply at the comments, the focus was not on gratitude. It was on the need for government organizations to provide more help. That is where I disagree: we are not all equally poised to face the same plight.
Conversely, I would argue that, since the 1940s when the arc began swinging from zero government safety net toward today’s entitlement-heavy culture, we have steadily increased the number of citizens who are in dire straits of need.
We are in a vicious cycle. As the government gets more involved, for example in areas such as education and health care, it drives up the costs. As the costs rise astronomically, most individuals cannot possibly pay for them. So, the government gets more involved driving the costs up even higher. Meanwhile, increasing reliance on the government eviscerates the ties between people leading, in the above examples, to the need for more medical care and the downfall of the educational system.
What used to happen when someone fell on hard times? They relied on family, friends, and neighbors. That worked because people had family, friends, and neighbors. There were work-related associations with their own benevolent societies; there were churches and synagogues who took care of their own. To this day, what happens when an Amish farmer’s barn burns down? Everyone around him steps up. While few people ever had that level of community, most people did shoulder the responsibility of being part of a group, whether business, religious, or social. They didn’t join primarily because they recognized that they might one day need assistance, but rather because that was part of being an adult human—looking out not only for oneself but also for others. The assumption was that marrying and having a family, undertaking employment, and contributing to your community were part and parcel of growing up.
I thank God that I have never faced a time when I didn’t know when I next could eat or where I would sleep. We have, more than once, opened our home to someone who was in such a situation. And, if God forbid I was in extreme trouble, I have no doubt that many people I know would help me. The government would not be my first, second, or third choice for a helping hand.
That is a great blessing. But it is one I participated in cultivating. It is a tragedy of our times that so many people have no one in their lives upon whom to call. A government can be neither loving nor charitable. It has obligations towards its citizens, but it is not a substitute for human interaction, where one heart responds to another. Are we all one step away from needing a government food bank? No. That is not a universal truth. It is a modern creation that conceals an uncomfortable reality. Our spiritually broken society is creating far too many people who do not expend the time and effort to build relationships nor even realize the importance of doing so.
Enjoyed this article? Feel free to share it using this link: https://rabbidaniellapin.com/one-step-away/
What do you think? We’d love to hear your thoughts on this Susan’s Musings post.
We Happy Warrior members can both read and write comments HERE.
Not a member yet? Susan’s Musings is a reader-supported publication.
We truly appreciate those of you who sign up for a Basic membership. This lets us know we are providing value to you.

Want a glimpse into the We Happy Warriors Membership?
We’ve created a special sneak peek to share just a few of the powerful resources our members enjoy—like Eye on Israel, where Rabbi Daniel and Susan Lapin offer unique, personal insights into the remarkable events unfolding in Israel and their global impact.
Get inspired, feel connected, and discover the value of being part of a purpose-driven community.



