Dear Rabbi Daniel and Susan Lapin,
Would you marry this woman? I’ve found myself in a predicament that I cannot escape or handle.
I grew up in a Christian family that went through some tough times due to bad behavior by my father. I have been very involved with the church and have a well-paying job. Unfortunately, I played around on Tinder a lot. Through that, about five years ago, I met a young lady. We seem to be a good match. Since we live in two different countries, we have only met a few times in person. Unfortunately, we have slept together whenever we met. I have tried breaking up a few times, but I keep coming back to her.
I am not blaming anyone; it was wholeheartedly my advances. Now I don’t want to let her go, but at the same time I know that is not the right thing given my beliefs. What will I say to my children once they grow up? Oh, I was looking for validation, downloaded tinder, and now that’s your mom? To compound this situation even more it was both of our first times. I feel like marriage would be a mockery to God as we’ve already done something that shouldn’t have been done.
Ultimately, I think we were two lonely kids when we met (22 and 20) and this long-distance relationship helped us get through the tough times. But now I’m as lost as ever, do I dump her and follow the right path with another woman from church or do I continue and mock God with my choices?
Regards
M.
Dear M.
This was a difficult letter to read as you are clearly in much pain. Confusion is one source of sadness. While things are confused, you remain mired in the problem. Even when news is difficult, once you face the reality you can start working your way through it. In that spirit, let’s see if we can help you sort through some of the thoughts that are in your letter.
You behaved in a way that does not make you proud and that contradicts the vision you have of yourself as a moral and religious man.
We hope to provide you with fresh perspectives that will help you decide on the best course of action. It may help you to know that from a Biblical angle, two single people sleeping together is far from the worst form of sexual misbehavior. For example, a liaison with a married woman is considerably more serious. An affair between a woman and her nephew is also more serious.
Furthermore, and perhaps this is most important for you, if a single man and single woman sleep together (and they are not prohibited from marriage by virtue of being, say, a brother and sister) the act of intimacy constitutes a significant step to marriage. So, be aware, you and the young lady, in God’s eyes, are already bonded and connected in an important way! So, why not embrace it wholeheartedly and both seriously commit before God and your community, to build a marriage, a family, and a future together?
We human beings cannot undo the past. We think you are on the wrong path with these two statements: “I feel like marriage would be a mockery to God as we’ve already done something that shouldn’t have been done,” and “Do I dump her and follow the right path with another woman from church or do I continue and mock God with my choices?”
Here is another way of looking at the situation: “I feel like marriage would please God as that would be a way of taking responsibility for our mistake,” and “Do I dump her, cause her great pain, then ignore her pain and pretend that the past doesn’t exist while moving on to a new woman?”
You have already formed a connection with this woman that cannot be undone. Why would it mock God to formalize it? Imagine if this young lady had gotten pregnant. Would her having an abortion erase your actions or would it aggravate them?
Your concern for your future children is misplaced. They will best thrive with a principled, mature, moral father who is solidly committed to their mother. Whether or not you share your past with them and how to do so is less important than who you become. And “dumping” a woman that you wronged (by sleeping with her) is not the action of a mature and moral man.
One further important point, you tell us that you and the young lady are one another’s first and only partners. This is an enormous plus in the statistics of successful marriages. The likelihood of divorce climbs meteorically with the number of previous partners experienced by both spouses.
Having said that, we have no way of knowing if the two of you can make a strong and lasting marriage. We do think that you need to take steps to try and do so. One possibility is enlisting an exemplary couple from your church to host this young woman on an extended visit to your country (shall we say one month?). Naturally, you would need to commit that she will not lose out financially should the two of you decide that marriage is not in your future. During this time, you would court her in a proper and respectful way.
She may or may not be thinking along the same lines. However, you need to clearly move this relationship towards marriage or to completely end it. Either way, repentance for past actions is in order, however repentance includes being able to move forward and not being stuck in past mistakes.
We hope this gives you a different way of thinking.
Keep in touch,
Rabbi Daniel and Susan Lapin
What do you think? We’d love to hear your thoughts on this Ask the Rabbi & Susan post.
We Happy Warrior members can both read and write comments HERE.
Not a member yet? Ask the Rabbi is a reader-supported publication.
We truly appreciate those of you who sign up for a Basic membership. This lets us know we are providing value to you.



