My brother has gone crazy with the “flat earth” theory and is coming up with “Biblical” proof. What are your thoughts on this and do you have proof otherwise? Of course, I believe we are on a globe earth and not in a flat covered by a dome.
Thank you,
Ron S.
Dear Ron,
The holiday season seems like a good time to answer this question as many of us will be surrounded by family members who, shall we say, have different beliefs than we do. We use the word ‘belief’ intentionally. Disagreements about facts, when both sides recognize that this is factual data, can be resolved rather simply. Differences of opinion can be tolerated and even celebrated. Differences of belief require maturity to navigate.
Before we explain what we mean, since you asked for our opinion, we would like to note that there is absolutely no Biblical support for the flat earth theory. Since the same Creator who built the earth as a sphere is the Creator who gave his word to mankind on Mt Sinai, there can clearly be no conflict between the two.
Now, back to how to deal with relatives who insist otherwise. We’d like to give an example of each of the three options we mentioned above, differences about facts, differences of opinion, and differences of belief.
- I (Susan) used to occasionally listen to Candace Owens. I realized that she had gone out of the reasonable zone after the following. She made a factually incorrect comment that Moslems in Jerusalem were restricted to living in the Moslem quarter. It is very easy to prove that this is false. Yet, when questioned on her words, instead of saying, “Oh, this is what I heard, can you show me where I might be wrong?” she doubled down that a rabbi had told her that so it must be true.
The equivalent would be if someone said that Van Gogh painted the Mona Lisa. This really isn’t open for debate. He did or he didn’t. (He didn’t.) Anyone who insists that he did and responds to pushback with, “Well, an art teacher told me that,” is not interested in the truth. They are either highly unintelligent (Candace isn’t) or they have an agenda. (Bingo!). - On the other hand, if I say that Van Gogh’s Starry Night is the most beautiful painting and you opine that Monet’s Waterlily Pond is, we have a difference of opinion. It would be silly to argue about it. I prefer pizza and you prefer hamburgers. I like chocolate ice cream and you like vanilla. We can appreciate our differences.
- If I believe that children need a mother and a father and that the lack of either of those leaves a hole that needs to be filled, and you believe that one parent or two mothers or two fathers is perfectly acceptable, then we will find it difficult to agree on laws governing education, adoption, foster parenting, and other topics. We can remain courteous neighbors if both of us exhibit humility, maturity, and respect, but there will be areas where we will need to draw lines.
It sounds like your brother believes in the Flat earth theory. We don’t think that buying him a collection of astronomy, geography, and physics books will change his mind. That rules out our first type of disagreement. From your perspective, this isn’t a difference of opinion, it’s nutty. However, to retain warm family relationships, we urge you to treat it as a difference of opinion (option #2) rather than a difference in belief (option #3). As long as you don’t embark on an ocean crossing together in a small sailboat, this does not impact your life. There are thousands of other topics you can discuss. Seek those out.
Keeping good relationships with family members sometimes means closing our eyes and covering our ears. If the issue is one that doesn’t affect our lives, it is best to do so.
Long-time sailors who have seen that the earth curves,
Rabbi Daniel and Susan Lapin
Enjoyed this article? Feel free to share it using this link: https://rabbidaniellapin.com/my-brother-believes-in-nutty-theories/

CYBER MONDAY – ONE DAY ONLY
🎉 25% OFF Annual Membership Plans
Basic Membership • Special Access Plus Membership
Become part of a community where ancient Jewish wisdom meets real-life application—faith, family, finances, friendships, and so much more.
Whether you are joining for the first time, upgrading to Special Access, or gifting a membership to someone you care about, today is your perfect moment.
🕒 One day ONLY — ends at 11:59 PM PST, December 1, 2025
Use Code: CYBERMONDAY25
(Available for new memberships, upgrades, or for gifting.)




Sure, the Earth is round, but often it’s the flat-Earther who can better defend his beliefs against a round-Earther, who’s never had his understanding challenged. *Why* do we believe the Earth is round, other than the fact that everyone says it is? What test can we run? A Foucault pendulum comes to mind, which you can see at a museum; the rotation of the Earth causes the pendulum to change direction over the course of a day. But the flat-Earther responds that the museum pendulum is being acted upon artificially; the museum has a motor pumping energy into it so it won’t slow down, and this changes its direction. It turns out that’s true! What about an accelerometer, which reveals we are travelling at 1000 mph and changing direction as the planet rotates? The flat-Earther has an answer for that too! I have a certain respect for reasoned challenges, even if the assertion seems kooky. We’ve seen the powers-that-be dismiss perfectly reasonable speculations (such as a lab leak being the source of COVID, or the Hunter Biden laptop report) as conspiracy theories. This leads to the joke: Q: What’s the difference between a conspiracy theory and an established fact? A: About six months. Har har! But, yeah, on this one, I’ll go with the round Earth theory.
I’d say your brother is not being serious with you. So I would reply, “You know, you’re right the earth we stand on is flat and I can prove it.” “Here’s a carpenter’s leveler. Look this table is level. This house is level so it has to be on flat earth. When I go to the store, office or some other place they’re constructed on a flat surface. Now look at the Sun or Moon. Is it round and flat, like a pancake or are they like a globe? Then show him his needed proof by showing him recent pictures of the Sun and Moon. Then show him pictures of Earth from space.” He’s already seen them too and knows the Earth is like a globe. Would you feel better after you did that or would you feel like a fool for doing it? Do you see what’s going on here? How it’s affecting you? It’s sibling rivalry plain and simple. When you recognize that he will too.
Hi Ronald, kindly see Rabbi Daniel Lapin’s response:
Dear Ronald,
I find that life’s conundrums are simpler to solve when I restrain myself from trying to analyze the motives of other people. Almost never do I need to know WHY someone did something in order to determine HOW I should respond or react to his having done something. Is it sibling rivalry? You think so, but we shall never know. It doesn’t much matter. The only thing to determine is whether to engage in serious discussion attempting to PROVE he’s wrong or simply smilingly allow him his idiosyncrasy and let the relationship continue. We prefer the latter approach in this particular situation.
Cordially
RDL
I kept looking for the scriptural reference, Isaiah 40:22 (& others?) to the “Circle of the earth”; I think scriptures for the brother would have been helpful as well.
Hi Marion. Kindly see Susan Lapin’s response:
Marion, you can find all the references you want and they will not persuade someone who is not open-minded. You can also find references that the brother can argue – the four corners of the earth. This is not a war of Biblical verses – indeed, nothing should be. Biblical understanding matters, quoting snippets tends to confuse.
the earth is not flat even if the Koran says it is. Also we did go to the moon no matter what people claim.
Hi Steven. Kindly see Rabbi Daniel Lapin’s response:
Dear Steven–
I am not at all sure the Koran does claim the earth is flat. There are poetic and metaphoric phrases that suggest this but Islamic scholarship has long known that the earth is a sphere without contradicting Islamic doctrine.
Cordially
RDL