Money or Flexibility?

Dear Rabbi and Susan,

I am currently working a job that sustains my family but does not allow for much in the way of savings. But the benefits, both professionally and personally, are very good. Time off, health care, flexible work hours, having my son with me at work, etc. are better than at any other place I or my friends have worked. Yet, I could be making several tens of thousands of dollars more with my education and experience level. These jobs often have far less benefit though, like less healthcare coverage, time off, rigid work schedule, etc.

So my question is should I just go for the higher pay, or stay where I am? Please correct me if I am wrong, but it seems like in the past you generally say to go for the money. Am I wrong in thinking that is what I should do? What questions can my wife and I begin to ask that will help guide us in this decision. FYI – my wife does not work. She stays home raising our son.

Thank you!

Vinny

Dear Vinny,

Let’s start with giving a thumbs up to a few things you mentioned. Most importantly, we love the question you asked —not what you should do, but what questions you and your wife should ask to help guide you in your decision. And, of course, we think your son and the two of you gain immeasurably from your wife being home with him.

We are going to make an assumption on some details that were missing from your letter. We picture you and your wife being relatively young, your son as a baby or young child, and your being at the starting point of a career rather than very established.

You write of the following benefits of your present position: “Time off, health care, flexible work hours, having my son with me at work.” Of this list, health care is the outlier. That is a dollar and cents equation. Would a higher salary allow you to access as good or better health care than your present job offers? Do you need all the health care benefits you have or, as a young couple, do your needs tend towards good pregnancy coverage as well as being covered in an emergency or catastrophic, unexpected event? In other words, getting an annual “free” eye exam is nice, but it is not a reason to accept a salary that costs you more than the exam would.


Now let’s look at your other issues; they are all highly valued in today’s society and they all put a serious cap on earning ability. If you and your wife have wisely made the calculation that your family will flourish best by her giving full attention to your child(ren), then why is having your son with you at work important? Certainly, emergencies crop up. For many reasons, we encourage moms to develop good friendships with other young moms. One benefit is having friends on whom to rely on in an emergency, even if family is not available. Similarly, flexible work hours are lovely, but if you are shouldering the job of supporting your family, then these years are crucial for building your reputation and experience, not to mention, a nest egg. Why is flexibility vital to you? Ditto for time off.

Furthermore, if you indeed are at an early career stage of life, there is a cascading cost to earning less now than you could. That is to say, future positions may well set your value at or slightly above the figure at which you are currently setting your own value. The higher your earning now, the higher your future earnings will be. There is quite a significant cost associated with accepting less than you could earn. This is obviously less of a problem for someone close to the end of his career.

There are many fantasy cultural messages that our society beams at us. Among them is the idea that we are entitled to everything. High pay, meaningful work, easy working conditions, lots of free time and flexibility (often camouflaged by the phrase work/life balance). As you are noting, most companies provide high pay in return for dedicated work.

We recognize that the currents against successful marriage are strong. Women are seduced to expect their men to handle 50% of the home and family responsibilities. They are lured to see themselves as victims and desperately in need of “me time” and pampering. They are encouraged to disparage their husbands and their husband’s activities. For this reason, among the things you and your wife should discuss is how to ‘bulletproof’ your marriage and for her to find meaning, enjoyment, and satisfaction in her role.

It does not sound to us like the alternative employment you are considering is expecting you to work 24/7. That is clearly unacceptable. But not being able to run to a routine pediatrician appointment at 10 a.m.? Not doing half the grocery shopping, laundry, and meal preparation? Not being able to cut out a few times a week to go for a mid-day walk? Welcome to the real world of a man doing a man’s job.

Vinny, there are limited years in which it is easiest to build a financial nest and set yourself up for monetary success. They coincide with the years that are easiest for building a marriage and family. As we stress in our 5F program and our book The Holistic You, these (and 3 more areas) need to complete each other, not compete with each other. This can only happen when a husband and wife work as a team. The most important question for the two of you to discuss is whether you can appreciate, respect, and be grateful for the different roles you occupy, drawing you closer to each other rather than apart.

Of course, you want to spend time with your son and with your wife. One of the advantages of your wife being self-employed (otherwise known as a stay-at-home wife and mother) is that she has the flexibility to fit in with your work schedule. She can occasionally bring your son and a picnic lunch to your office and arrange his nap and bedtime routine to sync with your hours. She has the ability to creatively manage the family’s time. She can keep a sharp eye on your relationship. Family and finance? Working together, the two of you can keep both thriving.

Let us hear from you again,

Rabbi Daniel and Susan Lapin


What do you think? We’d love to hear your thoughts on this Ask the Rabbi & Susan post.
We Happy Warrior members can both read and write comments HERE.

Not a member yet? Ask the Rabbi is a reader-supported publication.
We truly appreciate those of you who sign up for a Basic membership. This lets us know we are providing value to you.


Enjoy $10 OFF our Basic Annual Membership at
We Happy Warriors!

Our Basic Annual Membership includes:

  • Unlimited Weekly Wisdom: Get full access to our blogs — Thought Tools, Susan’s Musings, and Ask the Rabbi — offering fresh insights every week.
  • Access to the We Happy Warriors Community: Connect with like-minded individuals in a space filled with inspiration, meaningful challenges, and actionable tools for growth.
  • Exclusive Podcast Access: Dive deeper with members-only discussions and bonus episodes of the RDL Podcast.
  • Tailored Member Content and Support Across the Five Fs: Get ongoing encouragement and practical tools to grow in all five core areas of life: Faith, Family, Friendships, Finances, and Fitness.

We’d love to welcome you today! Use coupon code SAVE10
Only $45 for a full year of access

Shopping Cart