Is There a Future?

Prequel: I deliberately did not mention specific challenges like ICE, Minneapolis, Mamdani, Greenland, Iran, universities, gender transition and its backlash, or any other hot button topic. I leave it to the reader to apply these ideas to his or her own specific basket of worry spots.

A video circulated last week, showing the many Israeli soldiers involved in recovering the body of the last Hamas hostage, Ran Gvili. He voluntarily dove into danger on October 7, 2023, ignoring a shoulder injury that had him on sick leave from the police force, and fought heroically that day defending his fellow citizens. After he fell in battle, Hamas abducted his body to Gaza to be used as a bargaining chip.

Not everyone who saw the video recognized the song the soldiers were singing. It was not HaTikva, Israel’s national anthem nor was it a song of battle. It was one of thirteen essential foundations of Jewish faith, acknowledging that we fully believe in the coming of the Messiah and that even though he may tarry, we will wait for his arrival. (As the agreement with our Christian friends goes, upon the Messiah’s entry into Jerusalem, together we will ask him, “Is this your first time here?” Since we will all be happy with his answer, we can meanwhile join in cultural and political, if not theological, partnerships.)

Why is it so important that this is the song the soldiers, many of whom would adamantly insist that they are not religious, were singing? This is also the song that many Jews mournfully sang as they walked into the gas chambers in Nazi Europe, a fact that is probably unknown to many current Israelis.


Before answering that question, I need to ask another one: will the United States of America survive? I find it shocking that this question needs to be taken seriously, but it does.

At the time of the founding, John Adams wisely said, “Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people.”

Over a century later, Theodore Roosevelt opined, “The foundation stone of national life is and ever must be the individual character of the individual citizen.”

Society is difficult to build and easy to destroy. Destruction can be delivered in a hundred different ways. Countries can vanish by being conquered militarily, through neglect, and through malign political manipulation. I leave you to fill in 97 further ways. In contrast, building and sustaining takes constant and consistent attention and effort.

Morality and religion, the mainstays of which John Adams spoke, are themselves subject to weakness and corruption, as is happening today. The traditional American character, strong and compassionate as well as a blend of independence and interdependence, is hard to find. (Today, reading de Tocqueville’s reactions to early America that reveal those early qualities can bring one to tears.) Social media enhances negative forces and overshadows positive ones.

The early Pilgrims, Puritans, and colonial visionaries led the country onwards, with fits and starts, errors and corrections. They foresaw the unique opportunity this special land offered. Egregious mistakes were made in the 250 years since independence, but the foundations were refined and reinforced. Whether that is still happening is not certain.

America does not have an essential promise that no matter what suffering and loss ensues, there will be a national future redemption. Like other countries, the United States, in the iteration that officially began in 1776, can morph and disappear, to be replaced by a different variation as has happened in so many other countries.

Yet there is hope in what I acknowledge is a discouraging Musing. It lies in recognizing what our enemies know. There is a unique affiliation between the United States and the promises made to the children of Israel. Those who wish America ill, like Iran and Islamists, understand that you can test methods to defeat America by discovering how successfully you can demonize Israel and Jews. China knows that you can twist American laws to lead her to political suicide.

There are individuals and groups who are valiantly and repeatedly fighting back. Despite losses, they are notching some gains. Anyone not joining and supporting these warriors is bolstering the other side.

In the final analysis, only in the refining in both the personal and public life of the individual citizens of whom Theodore Roosevelt spoke, and in the wise and courageous stands of John Adam’s moral and religious people can Americans too, look to a promising future no matter how painful the present may be.

Enjoyed this article? Feel free to share it using this link: https://rabbidaniellapin.com/is-there-a-future/



What if the Bible you’ve read for years has layers you’ve never seen?

That’s what students tell us again and again after experiencing Scrolling through Scripture.

When Scripture is studied in its original Hebrew, nothing is random.

Every word. Every letter. Even every pause carries meaning.

What once felt familiar suddenly becomes rich, precise, and alive.

 “I liked best getting a more complete translation of the scriptures. I come away appreciating and being even more in awe of God.” ~Wendy W.

👉 Start your FREE lesson today and experience Scrolling through Scripture as it was meant to be read.

2 thoughts on “Is There a Future?”

  1. Is Israel/USA a philosophy or specific geographical region on planet earth with boundaries? What happens when the sun becomes a red giant expanding in size? The planet earth will at that point in time of the sun lifecycle be within the sun’s corona. All life will disappear from planet earth. Does Israel and the USA disappear when that happens? Or does the earth colonist carry with them Israel/USA thought system with them during the final eternal diaspora? How does this relate to the Hamas/Israel conflict – theme of your talk?If Israel/USA is a thought system – and not a specific ethnic group (White Anglo Saxon Protestants or Jews) – then the conflict ends with the expansion of the thought system. The “us” versus “them” dissapears. As long as “us” versus “them” exists – the wars in the Middle East will continue until the final eternal diaspora in my opinion.

  2. There is no guarantee of a future of the US there is really only a future guarantee for Israel though there are rough times as well based on the writings if Zechariah.

Comments are closed.

Shopping Cart