Finally, a Safe and Reliable Vaccine

By the time Solomon built his Temple, about 1,000 years before Jesus walked the streets of Jerusalem, the Jews had been living on a strip of land on the eastern shores of the Mediterranean for quite a while.

About 400 years after Solomon’s Temple was built, the Babylonians destroyed Jerusalem, expelling the Jews from their land. The displaced Jews settled largely in what today is Iraq and Syria, prospering and building schools, businesses and communities. As an example, the Sassoon family of Baghdad, who by the 18th century had already created one of the largest trading companies in the world, was originally part of the cohort of Jews forcibly removed from Israel. One of their descendants was Rabbi Solomon David Sassoon with whose son I studied in Bible seminary many years ago.

Eventually many Jews found their way back to what the Bible calls Eretz Yisrael, the Land of Israel and rebuilt the country and the Temple. That didn’t last too long before the Romans arrived, destroyed the Temple, and threw all the Jews out of their land–about 2,000 years ago. Many of the exiles moved westwards establishing the Jewish communities of Morocco, Libya, Algeria, and Egypt where they flourished for centuries until being thrown out when the State of Israel was founded in 1948.

Meanwhile, the remaining Jews thrown out of Israel by the Romans moved into Europe, gradually establishing the Jewish communities of France, England, Germany, Italy, Poland, and Russia. Susan and I have sat in the stone pews of a ruined synagogue outside Rome which had been built early in this period of Jewish settlement in Europe, about 2,000 years ago.

Over the centuries, many Jews trickled back to Israel, but of course the Crusades again evicted the Jews from their land. Later they wearily returned, only to be evicted again when the Ottomans cemented their control of the Middle East in the 15th century. Still, they came. For instance, the remarkable Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto born near Venice, Italy in 1707 took his family to settle in Israel near Haifa, where he died near the middle of the 18th century.

Wherever they found themselves after the latest eviction from their land, the Jews never saw themselves as refugees. Instead, they established themselves, succeeded and brought prosperity to the countries in which they settled. Throughout it all, century after century, Israel always remained home.


In 1948, after being attacked by all the surrounding Arab countries, for the first time since the Romans attacked more than 2,000 years ago, Jews picked up weapons. And because they were fighting for their country, they became quite accomplished fighters. Instead of being defeated and evicted as had been the common pattern, they prevailed. And remained.

One of the secret weapons that has protected Jews for millennia is a safe and reliable vaccine against the virus of seductive but false ideas. One of the most dangerous of these is the notion that the only moral military response is a “proportional” response, whatever that means. Pope Francis has thus condemned Israel’s attempts to subdue Hezbollah and allow more than seventy thousand Israeli citizens to return to their homes in northern Israel. Exploding pagers? Disproportionate! Taking out Nasrallah? Disproportionate! Destroying caches of weapons intended for use in an October 7th-style mass raid into Israel? Disproportionate!

If an armed, home-invading thug launches his depredation against your family by slapping your wife, is the only moral response to slap him back? Does the Pope really believe this? Widespread adoption of this silly idea is why America has not won a single war into which it has needlessly plunged its young men since 1945. Obviously, withholding overwhelming force in accordance with the dumb doctrine of proportionality is a sure formula for endless wars with no durable resolutions. Not only has America been incapable of winning a war since World War 2, she has resolutely prevented her allies from winning wars as well.

Proportionality in military response is a dangerous idea–a virus rooted in secularism, which the Jewish people have largely been protected from by their secret vaccine–ancient Jewish wisdom. Even young Jewish children proficient in Bible study know that regardless of how ‘moral’ or ‘good’ an action seems, it may not be deemed such until its 2nd and 3rd order consequences have been studied. Proportionality seems moral–it even seduced the Pope- but consider the highly destructive 2nd order consequences–endless war. World War 2 was not ended by the application of proportionality. It was won, and the deadliest war in history ended, by the application of wildly disproportionate force.

It was none other than Italian Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto who, in 1740, clearly wrote down these well-known, Biblically based principles in the 20th chapter of his famous book, The Path of the Righteous. Ignoring 2nd and 3rd order consequences of pretty-seeming actions is the folly of secularism imperiling societies vulnerable to the virus. The vaccine has been quite effective for generations of Jews. There is no reason why this reliable vaccine cannot be safely administered to all.


What do you think? We’d love to hear your thoughts on this Thought Tools post.
We Happy Warrior members can both read and write comments HERE.

Not a member yet? Thought Tools is a reader-supported publication.
To support our work, consider signing up for a Basic membership and join the conversation.


JEWISH FESTIVALS SALE
20% OFF THIS WEEK!

Genesis – Creation: Unit One


Genesis chapter 1 contains Foundational Principles for your life. This eye-opening 20-session program explores the original Hebrew through the lens of ancient Jewish wisdom.


Our offices will be closed for Rosh Hashanah
(Jewish New Year) and Shabbat:
From sunset on Wednesday, October 2nd (Pacific Time), reopening on Monday morning, October 7th.

Shopping Cart