As technology filters what we read, promoting to us only items that agree with our views, I deliberately subscribe to a few left-leaning blogs. With the notable exception of God, none of us are privy to absolute truth and I do want to know when reasonable arguments and cogent points are made in opposition to “my side.”
One of those blogs recently called out by name several people who were reliably on the Left for many years but who have moved away from the Democrat Party, often shocking themselves in the process. Many now support more conservative viewpoints and among them was ex-New York Times reporter, Bari Weiss.
I was an early subscriber to Bari’s newsletter, originally called Common Sense and now known as The Free Press. While I no longer subscribe, I do monitor her podcast. She recently shared a podcast interview aired by another podcaster I follow, Coleman Hughes, in which he interviewed three family members of kidnapped Israelis being held in Gaza. What drew my attention was Bari’s introduction to the interview. She said:
“This war is one where everyone has an opinion. But in my view, no opinion matters more than those of the families whose loved ones, including their children, are still being held captive by Hamas.”
Stop right there. I am grateful to Mr. Hughes and to Bari for keeping the plight of these hostages in the public eye. I have a list of their names posted in my prayer book in my own attempt to stay conscious of these men who are being starved and tortured. But I could not disagree more with Bari’s words. They illustrate a fatal flaw in her thinking.
Good people will support, pray for, and keep the prisoners and their families in their minds and hearts. If there are actions they can take, they will do so.
But giving great weight to the opinions of hostage families and individuals personally affected by tragedy is a terrible way to organize society or conduct an existential war. There is a reason that doctors don’t treat loved ones and why soldiers should not be under the direct supervision of their fathers. Emotions are necessary and valuable, but they manipulate our thinking, often in ways that make things worse, not better.
Years ago, a dear friend of mine shared the following exchange with me. She and her husband were in the excruciating position of watching their young son become weaker each day as cancer ravaged his body. As the end drew near, while they prayed for a miracle, they recognized the trajectory he was on. At the time, he was connected to a machine that was helping him, but that was in limited supply. My friend asked the doctor whether perhaps the machine was needed by someone who had a greater chance of survival. The doctor replied that the hospital staff might indeed come to that conclusion. But that wasn’t her responsibility. Her only job was to mother her son and lobby for whatever was best for him.
There is a body of literature that eloquently records the long tale of Jewish survival. Known generally as ‘Responsae” it contains tens of thousands of letters to rabbis asking questions ranging from the mundane to the heartbreaking along with the rabbinic responses. Throughout the centuries, tragic circumstances regularly reoccur in various forms. They probe the limits placed on protecting someone you love when someone else will pay the price.
If the Tsarist government in Russia takes my ten-year-old son to the army, can I bribe someone to exchange him for my neighbor’s son?
I have enough money to buy one set of false papers. Do I purchase them for myself even though my younger brother is in better health and might have a greater chance of survival?
The government is demanding ten men from our community to be executed in retaliation for one of their soldiers being killed. If they are not handed over, the entire village will be burned. What is the right thing for us to do?
Terrible questions that need immensely wise and almost Divine answers. None of the answers will eliminate suffering. What they do accomplish is to allow the questioner peace of mind knowing that they followed the best path. The questioner is not objective; the best course of action may be one that leads them to immense pain. They cannot be expected to choose that option for themselves.
Hostage families were drawn together by an external challenge. While I have not yet finished listening to Coleman’s interview, I expect that they have different views about negotiation, submitting to terrorist demands or not, and Israel’s political leadership. They all deserve our empathy and prayers.
However, when it comes to directing military and social policy, their opinions cannot be placed above others. Believing that the more emotional one is, the louder voice one should have is the type of fatal mistake that democratic societies make that leads to their demise. That road leads to unexpected consequences not only for individuals, but for the civilized world at large.
Enjoyed this article? Feel free to share it using this link: https://rabbidaniellapin.com/destruction-by-emotion/

LIVE Masterclass
Persuade with Purpose
Have you ever wished you could confidently and successfully share your skills, products, convictions or ideas?
Everyone is in Sales – but not everyone knows how to sell.
Join Rabbi Daniel Lapin for this interactive class.
📅 Event Details:
Date: Wednesday, September 10, 2025
Time: 5:00 PM PT / 8:00 PM ET
Location: Live on Zoom
Replay: Unlimited access included
Length: 75–90 minutes (plus live Q&A)
💰 Pricing: $69



